Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I think that's what people are trying to tell you. You say "Europe" like it's a thing. A monolithic entity that needs to address the complex problems that exist in Africa. But Europe is not a thing. It's has a complex set of its own problems. Gates is using "Africa" as a shorthand for the same reasons you used "Europe" as a shorthand, because it makes it easier to

1. Deliver the message quickly and clearly and

2. Bring people to the discussion who don't or can't have a complexed or nuanced view of the problem, but would like to do something to help.

I, for example, may have money to donate or some skill to assist, but I don't really want to commit myself to understanding "Africa". I'd rather leave that in the hands of someone who does understand it. That's what people who try to gain the limited attention of the public do, oversimplify. And regardless of what the public says, they want that simplification. My head would spin if I had to know every nuance of every specialty just to make a decision.

Also, Italy was hardly a colonial power in Africa, but Belgium was. So we're back to sum up a difficult history to a way people can wrap their heads around it enough to write a check.



Gates used "Africa" as a shorthand next to "safari" and "wild animals", which unfortunately is what many people think when they think of "Africa". I have no problem with the word Africa, but I do have a problem when people use it and reinforce those stereotypes.

All I'm trying to do is point out that those notions are part of the problem.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: