Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> All in one systems with water heating are way too complex and _will_ fail relatively quickly, ...

Can you offer some evidence of this? I don't see how adding a refrigerant to water heat exchanger after the compressor, before the reversing valve, could possibly hurt the longevity of a system.

> ... mini heat pumps won't last 10 years, and by the time it dies you won't be able to find a replacement for your specific model

Thing with mini-splits is you replace the entire unit so it doesn't matter.



> Can you offer some evidence of this? I don't see how adding a refrigerant to water heat exchanger after the compressor, before the reversing valve, could possibly hurt the longevity of a system.

The nearly infinite amount of forum posts about heat pumps dying prematurely and costing thousands and thousands to fix. You don't see how adding complexity on top of complexity in a complex system add points of failures ?

> Thing with mini-splits is you replace the entire unit so it doesn't matter.

I forgot this is an american centric forum and things are just made cheap/disposable because "it's cheaper'


> You don't see how adding complexity on top of complexity in a complex system add points of failures ?

I don't see see a heat pump as complex. It's a compressor, valves and coils. The complexity are the stupid computers foisted onto us.

> I forgot this is an american centric forum and things are just made cheap/disposable because "it's cheaper'

We don't have a choice. Do you? We're all at the mercy of the manufactures.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: