Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

I've had updates break Linux machines.

Just a few weeks ago I had an OpenBSD box render itself completely unbootable after nothing more than a routine clean shutdown. Turns out their paranoid-idiotic "we re-link the kernel on every boot" coupled with their house-of-cards file system corrupted the kernel, then overwrote the backup copy when I booted from emergency media - which doesn't create device nodes by default so can't even mount the internal disks without more cryptic commands.

Give me the Windows box, please.



Counter anecdote: I’ve been using Linux for 20 years, nearly half of that professionally. The only time I’ve broken a Linux box where it wasn’t functional was mixing Debian unstable with stable, and I was still able to fix it.

I’ve had hardware stop working because I updated the kernel without checking if it removed support, but a. that’s easily reversible b. Linux kept working fine, as expected.

I’ll also point out, as I’m sure you know, that the BSDs are not Linux.


Funny, i broke my Debian twice (on two separate laptops) by doing exactly that, mixing stable with testing. I was kinda obliged to use "testing" because Dell XPS would miss critical drivers.

I switched to opensuse afterwards


In fairness, this is the number one way listed [0] on how to break Debian. That said, if you need testing (which isn’t that uncommon for personal use; Debian is slow to roll out changes, favoring stability), then running pure Sid is actually a viable option. It’s quite stable, despite its name.

[0]: https://wiki.debian.org/DontBreakDebian


you are comparing a broken bicycle to a trainwreck




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: