Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Ask HN: Why so many projects set their GitHub links to /stargazers?
14 points by novoreorx on Aug 8, 2022 | hide | past | favorite | 7 comments
I really don't understand the point of showing who have starred the project. When I open a link that ends with /stargazers, I immediately click the project name to navigate to the home page. But since I have seen too many of these, I want to ask why, maybe there are some considerations I don't know.

(Just met two "stargazer" links in the past 30 minutes: https://github.com/formkit/auto-animate/stargazers , https://github.com/payloadcms/payload/stargazers)



It's analytics. Google search brings up

https://www.cockroachlabs.com/blog/what-can-we-learn-from-ou...

"Years ago I dedicated a Flex Friday (our version of 20% time) to stargazers, a tool to query the CockroachDB repository for information about its GitHub stars and analyze the results. At the time of writing, we had 6,000+ stars (which felt like a lot), and the data in this blog will be based on that original set of 6,000 stargazers."

Which links to

https://github.com/spencerkimball/stargazers

"GitHub allows visitors to star a repo to bookmark it for later perusal. Stars represent a casual interest in a repo, and when enough of them accumulate, it's natural to wonder what's driving interest. Stargazers attempts to get a handle on who these users are by finding out what else they've starred, which other repositories they've contributed to, and who's following them on GitHub."


This doesn't answer OP's question. OP asks why projects link to the page showing who starred them, not what some tool named stargazers does or/and what data can be gathered from people that starred a project.

edit: Thinking about it, probably does. Basically someone will check the stargazers page to find what people that have starred a particular project are up to or what else they may have found. This may seen as a waste of time on projects with numerous stars but becomes really useful in small niche projects with low number of stars.


Hm, I never experienced this. The links I usually visit link to the github page.


>Just met two "stargazer" links in the past 30 minutes

Do you met those through the GitHub button shown on their homepage? The left part ("Star") will take you to the project's repo home, whereas the right part (number of people that starred project) will take you the stargazers page. It's kinda unintuitive since they appear like they perform an action but only the fork button does.


Exactly, seems most of them are from https://ghbtns.com/, which is not an official GitHub tool. If GitHub can make a special page to confirm starring the project, it would be ideal to use in this situation.


My impression is that it's the Github equivalent to YouTube's ubiquitous "Please Like and Subscribe".


Yes, but YouTube doesn't have a page to show the subscribers of a channel lol




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: