Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

We'll need a better answer to deepfakes than "You cannot do anything with an image of another person's face."

Unless we want to be governed by faceless legislators or entertained by faceless celebrities. There should be some way to divide responsibility for person's images that isn't totalitarian in either direction (either "You cannot use a person's face without their consent," which kills visual news as a practice, or "every face is fair game for anyone to use at any time," which feels invasive to the individual).



I agree; in retrospect my comment was a bit facile. In the long run I don't think anyone will have any rights with respect to images of her or his own (clothed or naked) body. We're not in the long run yet. It will take some time for most of us to be comfortable with that.

In my view, it's more important to create a sort of symmetry with respect to images and other data than it is to preserve particular customs that are problematic in light of modern technology. That is, it's probably OK that every e.g. FBI agent has access to thousands of images of me, or even my complete genome, as long as I have access to thousands of images and the complete genome of every FBI agent. We learned in kindergarten that "knowledge is power". Like power, knowledge is not symmetrical. A federal prosecutor having power over me doesn't necessarily mean I have power over that federal prosecutor.

If we've learned anything in the decade just past (to be clear, that's an open question), it is that authoritarian structures are easily hacked by the authoritarians who run them. It may be that e.g. the Department of Justice wasn't always constructed to capriciously surveil and/or construct false cases against innocents (although, was that before or after they harassed MLK and other civil rights leaders?), but ISTM at least the cases of Aaron Swartz and Carter Page, to cover both ends of the political spectrum, show that to be the case now. If the tools of knowledge/power are increasing in power, we all need to have access to those tools.


I'm afraid I fail to see what Swartz has to do with this topic.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: